The first time I interviewed anyone about TMDLs, a frustrated state official told me the acronym actually stood for “too many d*** lawyers.” Two decades later, that still seems to be the case as courts are still hammering out what Congress intended when it wrote the few sentences in the Clean Water Act that talk about total maximum daily loads.
But for now, federal District Court Judge Sylvia Rambo may have offered some clarity, at least for the Bay, by upholding the Chesapeake Bay TMDL with a strongly worded decision. Eleven-and-a-half months after oral arguments on the suit, Rambo rejected every issue raised in a suit challenging the most detailed and complex cleanup plan of its type.
“This wasn’t a judge that just kind of whipped off a 10-page opinion,” said Jon Mueller, an attorney with the Chesapeake Bay Foundation, who was heavily involved in the case. “Ninety-eight pages is pretty darn long in my experience as a federal prosecutor. I think she covered all the bases and made a pretty ironclad decision.”
That said, there is still a lot of legal work for lawyers trying to resolve issues related to controlling nutrient and sediment pollution. Elsewhere in this issue, you will find Rona Kobell’s report about a West Virginia poultry farmer suing the EPA to get clarification over the extent of that agency’s ability to regulate animal feeding operations.
Other highlights to check out:
- Tom Horton’s latest installment in the Growing Concern series, which examines the implications of economic and population growth in the Bay watershed, explores the ongoing experiment which is Calvert County, MD, where county commissioners have consciously tried to draw a line on new growth — a stark contrast to most other jurisdictions around the region.
- With the ongoing dysfunction in Congress, Horton’s Chesapeake Born column about former Sen. Ed Muskie and the writing of the original Clean Water Act is also worth reading for a reminder that there actually was a time when our government seemed to work.
- For uplifting news, Whitney
- Pipkin explores plans to incorporate state-of-the-art stormwater controls — often associated with higher-end developments— on a planned affordable housing project in Lexington, VA.
- And, Leslie Middleton reports on efforts to bring the Chesapeake and its tributaries within reach of disabled paddlers who often find their access to waterways limited.
- All that and eels, eastern meadowlarks, U.S. National Wildlife Refuges, oyster aquaculture and much more. Enjoy!
Keep up with Bay Journal online
If you haven’t been checking out our website, you’ve been missing news and analyses posted by reporters on our blog on subjects as diverse as monarch butterflies to the ongoing debate over the failed suit brought by Waterkeepers earlier this year against an Eastern Shore poultry farmer.
It’s the new way to keep up with the latest information, or join the discussion by posting a comment, between new print issues of the Bay Journal.
And, if you haven’t already, you can like us on our updated Chesapeake Bay Journal Facebook page and follow us on Twitter @ChesBayJournal and @ChesBayJourneys, which will alert you to new postings on the website and much more.
We want your 2¢, not $$
In the next several weeks, some Bay Journal readers will receive a survey in the mail. This is not a fund-raiser. Thanks to generous support from the Town Creek Foundation, WBA Research is conducting a survey to help us better understand who is reading the Bay Journal, how they are using the information they get in the newspaper and what they value or would like to see more of in our news reporting.
This is the first time we will have had statistically valid information about our readership — but we need your help. If you are one of the randomly selected readers who receive the survey, please take a few minutes to fill it out and return it.